Unfortunately, the Cotton Bay Club has been closed since 1994. Even still, this beach is definitely worth taking the time to visit. The gently curving bay is reef protected so the warm and welcoming crystal clear water stays calm most of the time and the powdery pink sand stays relatively clean of any of the flotsam that can wash ashore on a lot of the Atlantic beaches. Cotton Bay Beach is not far from Jack’s Bay, so, if you are pressed for time while on the island, you could plan to visit both of these beaches on the same day.